The Garage Sale Mystery movies in order

In 2013, Lori Loughlin took on the role of Jennifer Shannon for the movie, Garage Sale Mystery. The film – a loose adaptation of Suzi Weinert’s novel, Garage Sale Stalker – saw Loughlin play the owner of an antiques store who also solves murders.

Garage Sale Mystery proved popular with audiences and this led to the development and release of further films in the series. Over the next few years the Garage Sale Mystery movies developed quite the following, with Loughlin appearing in every movie, alongside a cast which included Steve Bacic, Sarah Strange, Eva Bourne, Connor Stanhope and Kevin O’Grady.

But how many Garage Sale Mystery movies are there and what is the viewing order for the series? Read on for details – as there are probably more movies than you think.

—

The Garage Sale Mystery movies

Garage Sale Mystery (2013)

As noted above, the first entry in the Garage Sale Mysteries movie series made its debut in 2013 with Garage Sale Mystery. In this entry, garage sale bargain hunter, Jennifer Shannon gets drawn into a perplexing mystery when a string of burglaries hits her town.

Teaming up with Detective Adam Iverson, Jennifer aims to help crack the case. But things worsen when she discovers the dead body of her friend. (120 mins)

All That Glitters (2014)

The second entry in the Garage Sale Mysteries movie series arrived in 2014 under the title, All That Glitters. In this film, when Jennifer’s friend turns up murdered, she is pulled into yet another case as a key eyewitness. (87 mins)

The Deadly Room (2015)

In movie No. 3, The Deadly Room, another murder takes place, which this time is connected to a multi-million dollar house and a supposed ‘deadly curse’. Jennifer teams up with Detective Iverson to get to the bottom of the case. (83 mins)

The Wedding Dress (2015)

In The Wedding Dress, Jennifer looks into a cold case involving a wedding dress that was worn on the day a groom went missing. (83 mins)

Guilty Until Proven Innocent (2016)

In movie No. 5, Guilty Until Proven Innocent, an old college friend of Jennifer’s is accused of murder. Jennifer has no choice but to get involved to exonerate her friend. (84 mins)

The Novel Murders (2016)

In movie No. 6, The Novel Murders, there’s murder in the air once again as Jennifer stumbles upon the body of a customer. As the case unfolds, she soon realises the victim’s death is similar to a murder in a classic mystery novel. (84 mins)

The Art or Murder (2017)

For movie No. 7, The Art of Murder, Jennifer is in the process of organising a charity garage sale when she uncovers a body in the attic of a local residence. (84 mins)

The Beach Murder (2017)

A body washed up on a beach becomes the catalyst for this next instalment in the Garage Sale Mysteries movie series. It looks like an apparent surfing accident, but Jennifer knows better. (84 mins)

Murder By Text (2017)

In movie No. 9, the concert of a famous country singer is put in jeopardy when the entire crew receives a suicide note from the band’s bassist. (83 mins)

Murder Most Medieval (2017)

In Murder Most Medieval, Jennifer finds the body of a local college history professor hidden in a suit of armour. (84 mins)

A Case of Murder (2017)

In movie No. 11, A Case of Murder, when Jennifer buys an old reel-to-reel recorder at a garage sale, she discovers the sound of a man pleading for his life. (90 mins)

The Pandora’s Box Murders (2018)

The twelfth movie in the Garage Sale Mysteries movie series arrived in 2018 under the title, The Pandora’s Box Murders. This movie sees Jennifer caught up in another murder investigation, this time involving a mysterious puzzle box. (84 mins)

The Mask Murder (2018)

In The Mask Murder, Jennifer purchases a plaster mask from a storage locker auction. Once again, another murder comes into play. (84 mins)

Picture a Murder (2018)

In movie No.14, Picture a Murder, Jennifer acquires an antique camera from an estate sale. When she gets the photos developed, one of the pictures leads her to another murder mystery. (84 mins)

Murder in D Minor (2018)

In movie No.15, Murder in D Minor, Jennifer puts in a bid for a vintage piano at the estate auction of a wealthy philanthropist. This leads to Jennifer questioning if his death might have been connected to his wealth.(84 mins)

Search & Seized (2019)

In Search & Seized, Jennifer agrees to help a fellow antiques dealer by bidding on items at a police auction on his behalf. But when he turns up dead, she begins to investigate a counterfeiter with ties to the mob. (84 mins)

Murder Takes the Stage (2026)

Following a seven year hiatus, the Garage Sale Mysteries movie series continued in 2026 with movie No.17, Murder Takes the Stage. In this film, a member of Jennifer’s true crime book club is murdered. (84 mins)

__

The Garage Sale Mysteries movies in order

In total, there are 17 Garage Sale Mystery movies. Should you wish to watch the movies in order, follow this list:

• Garage Sale Mystery (2013)
• All That Glitters (2014)
• The Deadly Room (2015)
• The Wedding Dress (2015)
• Guilty Until Proven Innocent (2016)
• The Novel Murders (2016)
• The Art or Murder (2017)
• The Beach Murder (2017)
• Murder By Text (2017)
• Murder Most Medieval (2017)
• A Case of Murder (2017)
• The Pandora’s Box Murders (2018)
• The Mask Murder (2018)
• Picture a Murder (2018)
• Murder in D Minor (2018)
• Search & Seized (2019)
• Murder Takes the Stage (2026)

__

Who are the cast of the Garage Sale Mysteries movies and are the films the work of the same director?

Notable cast members in the Garage Sale Mysteries movie collection include: Lori Loughlin, Rick Ravanello, Andrew Dunbar, Sara Canning, Cameron Bancroft, Sarah Strange, Brendan Meyer, Anne Marie DeLuise, Britt Irvin, Kevin O’Grady, Janet Kidder, David James Lewis, Brenna O’Brien, Cheryl Ladd, Madison Ryne Smith, Rebecca Olson, Susan Hogan, Liza Huget, and John Murphy.

In terms of directors, the movies are the work of the following:

• Peter DeLuise directed Garage Sale Mystery, Guilty Until Proven Innocent, The Deadly Room, The Wedding Dress, and All That Glitters
• Norma Bailey directed The Novel Murders
• Kristoffer Tabori directed The Art of Murder
• Mel Damski directed The Mask Murder
• Neill Fearnley directed The Beach Murder, Murder by Text, Murder Most Medieval, A Case of Murder, The Pandora’s Box Murders, Picture a Murder, Murder in D Minor, and Searched & Seized

__

Which is the best Garage Sale Mysteries movie?

According to IMDb, the Garage Sale Mysteries movies are rated as follows:

• Garage Sale Mystery (2013) – 7.0/10
• All That Glitters (2014) – 6.9/10
• The Deadly Room (2015) – 7.0/10
• The Wedding Dress (2015) – 6.9/10
• Guilty Until Proven Innocent (2016) – 7.0/10
• The Novel Murders (2016) – 7.1/10
• The Art or Murder (2017) – 6.8/10
• The Beach Murder (2017) – 6.8/10
• Murder By Text (2017) – 6.8/10
• Murder Most Medieval (2017) – 6.8/10
• A Case of Murder (2017) – 7.0/10
• The Pandora’s Box Murders (2018) – 7.0/10
• The Mask Murder (2018) – 6.9/10
• Picture a Murder (2018) – 7.0/10
• Murder in D Minor (2018) – 7.0/10
• Search & Seized (2019) – 6.9/10
• Murder Takes the Stage (2026) – Not yet rated

—

__

Thank you for stopping by It’s A Stampede! to read this post about the Garage Sale Mysteries movie series. For more posts be sure to check out the recommended reads below.